Tuesday, January 29, 2013

Faithfulness over Efficiency

Of the many lessons I've learned in marriage, one of the most important is the need to choose one's words wisely.  For instance, one evening, having dinner with close friends, Kenzie and I were asked what the title of a book would be that chronicled our first year of marriage. My first response was "Pre-Marital Failure," which was an attempt to convey how I felt that pre-marital counseling, while helpful, did little to truly prepare Kenzie and I for the profound mysteriousness of marriage. Unfortunately, all Kenzie heard was that I thought our marriage was a failure. The moral of the story? Choose your words wisely, for they can communicate far more than you may intend.

This lesson is not only applicable in all marriages, relationships, and friendships, but I think we need to be mindful of this in the way we speak of God and the work he has beckoned us to join him in. For instance, as Christians, I think the words "effective" and "efficient" should be eradicated from our vocabulary when it comes to talking about ministry.  Eradicated?  Strong word I know, but I feel quite strongly about this.

I have no problem with people running an effective business or being mindful of more efficient ways to accomplish one's work. Effectiveness and efficiency communicate the importance of maximizing one's resources, finding the best way with a minimal amount of supplies to create the biggest net result. These words, if they could talk, might say, "We know the goal we're pursuing, but can we attain it in a better, faster, more productive way? Can we save time, energy, or money?"  Effectiveness focuses on results and the means by which those results are achieved.  And sometimes, when effectiveness is the highest priority, the means by which results are attained are uncritically accepted.  Then, it doesn't matter exactly how you do it as long as you get the most results. The ends begin to justify the means.

These words are great for a business, but horrible for the church. God is not concerned with effectiveness and efficiency, but faithfulness. God is not concerned just with the results, but with every step of the process.  Everything we do says something about who God is and what his Kingdom is like. With faithfulness, the goal is not results, but conformity to and unity with God.

I could see effectiveness and efficiency having a place within the church if the goal is the glory of God.  Effectiveness then becomes, "How can I maximize glory for God?" which is a lot more akin to faithfulness. But glory to God is a bit more intangible than, for instance, more people.  And efficiency and effectiveness tend to focus more on what we can see and measure. Eventually, over time, the ends will eclipse the means. Thus, if we removed the words altogether from our vocabulary, I think it would free us to faithfulness.

Some may think that I'm creating a false dichotomy here, which may be true. I just can't help but think about Jesus' ministry, who gave such difficult teachings that many walked away and abandoned him completely.  Effective?  Probably not. Faithful? He's the primary image of what faithfulness looks like.

2 comments:

  1. I agree, although one could attribute it to poor targets for our efficiency and effectiveness, namely attendance, conversions, and impact. But if we focus our target on living fully in the kingdom of God, we can talk about efficiency and effectiveness in a redeemed light. We may cut unhelpful buildings, programs, staff positions, bad habits, old paradigms, inaccurate perceptions, and false assumptions in order to be efficient in the Kingdom. We may spend more time with those outside our circles, with our neighbors, more time listening to the Holy Spirit in prayer, we may schedule times of rest and renewal, and create habits of listening to one another and accepting one another in order to be more effective in the Kingdom.

    I disagree that efficiency and effectiveness should be completely removed. I believe they can be redeemed by removing them from the conversation of "church growth" strategies and employing them in the conversation of Kingdom Faithfulness.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I see what your saying about how effectiveness and efficiency need to be redeemed from the "church growth strategies" but I wonder if that would really work. If the words have been so associated with a certain paradigm, using the same word but attaching new meaning to it might make things more confusing than helpful. That's why I think removing them and finding new words to communicate new ideas would be more beneficial. With new words, you won't have to do the legwork of removing the old baggage and crafting a new meaning.

      Delete